With her boyfriend and fellow auditioner Jonny West accompanying her on piano, Margie Mays returns after getting cut in Hawai'i last season for a second shot at at least making the Top 20.
Judge Katy Perry didn't think her song choice of 'I Found A Boy' by Adele was a good fit and shocks even herself by voting no.
Luke Bryan becomes the tie-breaker and compliments her improvement, his yes earning Margie her Golden Ticket.
From Season 3, Episode '302 (Auditions)'.
Watch American Idol SUNDAY 8|7c on ABC, streaming, on demand, and Hulu.